How Restaurants Can Decide Between In-House and Outsourced Delivery Drivers

How Restaurants Can Decide Between In-House and Outsourced Delivery Drivers - Expedite blog banner

Outsourced delivery drivers are drivers supplied by a delivery partner instead of hired onto your payroll. For most restaurants, outsourcing makes sense when order volume is uneven, catering orders are large and time-sensitive, or the team can no longer afford to spend hours scheduling drivers. In-house drivers make sense when volume is steady enough to keep them busy and you want full control of every handoff. Many operators end up with a mix of both.

This guide compares the two models on cost, control, risk and customer experience, and finishes with the questions to ask before you choose a partner.

Driver holding a phone with the Expedite driver app open while in the car

What Outsourced Delivery Drivers Are and How the Models Differ

“Outsourcing delivery” covers a few different setups, and they are not interchangeable:

  • Marketplace apps. The customer orders through a third-party app, and that app sends one of its own drivers. You get reach, but the app owns the customer relationship and charges commission on the order.
  • Delivery service partners. The order comes through your own website, phone line, catering platform or POS, and a delivery company supplies the driver. You keep the customer and pay for the delivery itself.
  • Hybrid fleets. Your own drivers cover routine runs, and a partner covers overflow, distant addresses or large catering drops.

Expedite is a delivery service partner. Restaurants send orders from their own app or website to trusted fleets through Expedite’s delivery network, and Expedite connects them with independent, professional drivers who specialize in catering and high-touch deliveries.

The Case for In-House Delivery Drivers

Running your own drivers has real advantages, and some restaurants should keep doing it.

  • Direct control. You hire, train and set the standard for anyone who shows up at the customer’s door.
  • Familiar faces. Regular office and catering clients get to know your drivers, and your drivers learn their buildings.
  • Flexibility between runs. A driver on the clock can help with prep, packing or dishes when there are no orders.

The catch is cost and management time. A staff driver needs wages, payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, mileage or a vehicle, and insurance that covers business use. For context, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports a median annual wage of $44,860 for light truck drivers in May 2025, before benefits and vehicle costs. Someone also has to build schedules, cover call-outs and replace drivers who leave.

The bigger problem is idle time. Delivery demand comes in peaks: a Friday lunch rush, a run of holiday parties, a slow Tuesday. A team sized for the peak sits around during the lull, and a team sized for the lull cannot cover the peak.

When Outsourced Delivery Drivers Make More Sense

Outsourcing tends to win in four situations:

  1. Volume swings. You pay for deliveries you actually make instead of shifts you scheduled.
  2. Catering is growing. Large orders need bigger vehicles, carts and drivers who can set up. Most restaurants cannot keep that kind of driver busy every day.
  3. You run several locations. Coordinating drivers across stores gets hard fast. A partner can cover each location from one system.
  4. Your managers are stretched. Every hour spent filling a driver shift is an hour not spent on food and guests.

Expedite’s restaurant delivery solutions are built for this. The restaurants page says there is “no in-house fleet needed,” and that Expedite “is designed to scale with your catering program” whether you have five locations or fifty.

Delivery driver holding out a set of car keys before a shift

In-House vs. Outsourced Delivery Drivers: Side by Side

FactorIn-house driversOutsourced drivers
Cost structureFixed wages, taxes, insurance, vehicle costsPer-delivery fee
Idle timeYou pay for itMostly removed
Hiring and schedulingYour managersThe partner
Control of the handoffDirectSet through standards, tracking and support
Capacity on peak daysLimited to your rosterScales with the network
Large catering dropsOnly if you own the vehicles and cartsDepends on the partner’s driver matching

Costs to Compare Before You Decide

Comparing a driver’s hourly wage with a per-delivery fee will mislead you. Put the full cost on both sides:

  • In-house: wages for every scheduled hour, payroll taxes, workers’ compensation, mileage or vehicle costs, insurance, recruiting, training and the manager time spent on scheduling.
  • Outsourced: the delivery fee per order, any minimums, and the cost of late or failed deliveries if the partner is unreliable.

Then divide the in-house total by the number of deliveries those drivers actually make in a typical month. Restaurants with a few predictable routes often find in-house cheaper. Restaurants whose volume doubles on some days and drops by half on others usually do not.

Risk, Classification and Insurance

Most delivery services work with independent contractors rather than employees, and the delivery company manages that relationship. If you build your own team, how you classify drivers matters. The IRS guidance on independent contractors and employees says the facts that show the degree of control and independence fall into three categories: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. Talk to your accountant or an employment attorney before you call a driver on your own schedule a contractor.

Insurance is the other open question. Many personal auto policies limit or exclude business use, so confirm what covers a driver, the vehicle and the food while an order is on the road.

What Catering Orders Need From Any Driver

Catering raises the bar for both models. A 40-person lunch with hot trays, utensils and a setup request is not the same job as a single takeout bag. Look for drivers who have the right vehicle and equipment, arrive on time without showing up too early, and leave photo proof of delivery.

Expedite builds its definition of a successful delivery around those points: accurate, on-time pickup and delivery, the right driver matched to the order, and a quality photo as proof of delivery. Its drivers are described as “setup pros” with professional delivery equipment. For more on the people side of the job, see our post on what catering delivery drivers do.

Questions to Ask an Outsourced Delivery Partner

  • Which markets do you cover, and do you cover all of my locations?
  • How are drivers vetted, and how are they matched to large or catering orders?
  • Can customers track the order live, and do they see my brand or yours?
  • What proof of delivery do I get?
  • Who do I call when something goes wrong, and when are they available?
  • Can I keep using my own drivers alongside yours?
  • How do orders get from my POS or ordering platform to your drivers?

Expedite’s answers are on its own pages. It delivers in more than 200 markets nationwide, offers live tracking and branded customer updates, and keeps a responsive support team of real people. Through the Expedite Driver App, you can use your own drivers, Expedite’s partner fleets, or a mix of both, so everyone works in the same system. If keeping your brand in front of the customer matters, read our guide to white label delivery for restaurants.

Key Takeaways

  • Outsourced delivery drivers turn fixed driver costs into a per-delivery fee and remove most idle time.
  • In-house drivers give you direct control, but you carry wages, insurance, vehicles, scheduling and turnover.
  • Compare the full cost per delivery, not hourly wage against delivery fee.
  • Catering orders need the right vehicle, equipment, on-time arrival and photo proof, whoever drives.
  • A hybrid setup, with your own drivers plus a partner for overflow and catering, is often the most practical choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are outsourced delivery drivers?

Outsourced delivery drivers are drivers who are not on your payroll. They come through a delivery service, a marketplace app or a fleet partner, and you pay per delivery or per order instead of paying wages, mileage and insurance for your own staff.

Is it cheaper to outsource restaurant delivery?

It depends on volume. Outsourcing turns driver costs into a per-delivery fee and removes idle time, vehicle costs and hiring. A restaurant with steady, high volume may find an in-house driver costs less per order, while one with uneven or seasonal volume usually pays for a lot of idle time with its own staff.

Can I use my own drivers and outsourced drivers together?

Yes. Many restaurants keep a small in-house team for regular routes and send overflow or large catering orders to a partner. Expedite supports this: you can use your own drivers on the Expedite Driver App, Expedite’s partner fleets, or a mix of both.

Who is responsible if an outsourced driver is late?

Your contract and your partner’s support process decide that. Before you sign, ask how late or failed deliveries are reported, who contacts the customer, and how problems get fixed. A partner with live tracking and a real support team will spot a late order sooner.

Are outsourced delivery drivers employees?

Usually not. Most delivery services work with independent contractors, and the delivery company, not the restaurant, manages that relationship. The IRS looks at behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship to decide whether a worker is an employee or a contractor.

If you want to compare your current setup with an outsourced driver network, schedule a demo with Expedite today.

Share this article

Ready to see how Expedite handles your deliveries?

Tell us about your locations and order volume, and we’ll show you how Expedite handles the road while your team handles the food.

Resources

Keep reading

View all articles